How Github Copilot Helps in Auditing Logging Practices

How Github Copilot Helps in Auditing Logging Practices

GitHub Copilot for Security
GitHub Copilot for Security
GitHub Copilot for Security

Ankita Gupta

Ankita Gupta

Ankita Gupta

Audit logging is an essential part of security and compliance in software systems, providing a historical record of operations and changes. Proper logging practices can help in the detection of security incidents, performance issues, and fraudulent activities. However, inadequate logging practices can introduce security risks, such as exposing sensitive information or failing to record crucial events.


Consider the following logging setup in a Python application:

import logging

logging.basicConfig(filename='app.log', level=logging.INFO)

def log_user_access(user):
    logging.info(f"User {user.name} accessed the system at {user.last_login}")

def log_error(error):
    logging.error(f"An error occurred: {error}")

In this example, user access and errors are logged with basic details.

Engaging GitHub Copilot:

Prompt to GitHub Copilot: "Assess these logging practices for security concerns."

Anticipated Copilot Analysis:

GitHub Copilot would review the provided logging practices and might respond with:

The current logging practices have several areas that could be improved for security:

1. **Sensitive Information**: Logging user names can be considered sensitive information. Be cautious with logging identifiable user data. Consider logging user IDs or anonymized identifiers instead to comply with privacy standards like GDPR.

2. **Log Level Appropriateness**: Ensure that log levels are appropriately used. For example, sensitive actions or significant failures should be logged at higher importance levels, such as WARN or ERROR, to distinguish them from routine operations.

3. **Error Details**: While logging errors, ensure that sensitive data is not included in the log. Also, provide enough context to understand the error's nature and impact without exposing details like stack traces to unauthorized readers.

4. **Log Tampering**: There is no mention of log integrity mechanisms. Ensure that logs are immutable and protected from tampering. Consider using log management solutions that support tamper-evident features.

5. **Log Access**: Ensure that access to logs is restricted to authorized personnel. Logs containing sensitive information should be encrypted and stored securely.

6. **Log Retention**: Define and implement a log retention policy that balances the need for historical data with privacy and storage considerations.

7. **Incident Detection and Alerts**: There is no indication that the logging setup is integrated with an incident detection or alerting system. Implement monitoring on the logs to detect and alert on suspicious activities.

Here is a revised example that addresses some of these concerns:

import logging
from logging.handlers import RotatingFileHandler

# Set up a rotating log handler to limit log size and backup count
handler = RotatingFileHandler('app_secure.log', maxBytes=50000, backupCount=5)
logging.basicConfig(handlers=[handler], level=logging.INFO)

def log_user_access(user):
    # Log using user ID instead of name
    logging.info(f"User ID {user.id} accessed the system.")

def log_error(error, context):
    # Log error with context, avoiding sensitive data
    logging.error(f"An error occurred in {context}: {str(error)}")

Incorporating these recommendations will enhance the security and usefulness of your logging practices.

  • Over-reliance on AI Assistance: While GitHub Copilot can provide valuable insights, it's important to remember that it's a tool and not a substitute for a security expert. It may not catch all potential issues, and its suggestions should be reviewed by a human expert.

  • Limitations in Context Understanding: GitHub Copilot assesses the code based on the given context. If the context is not clear or insufficient, it may not provide the most accurate or complete advice.

  • Lack of Detailed Review: If the user doesn't thoroughly review and understand the suggestions provided by GitHub Copilot, they may inadvertently introduce new issues into their logging practices.

  • Absence of a Security Framework Reference: GitHub Copilot might not always provide recommendations based on a specific security framework. For accurate and detailed recommendations, it is better to refer to established security guidelines and frameworks.

  • Overlooking Data Privacy Concerns: GitHub Copilot can suggest logging more information for better transparency and debugging. However, this may lead to over-logging and potential privacy concerns if not carefully considered.

On this page

Protect your APIs from attacks now

Protect your APIs from attacks now

Protect your APIs from attacks now

Explore more from Akto


Be updated about everything related to API Security, new API vulnerabilities, industry news and product updates.


Browse and register for upcoming sessions or catch up on what you missed with exclusive recordings

CVE Database

Find out everything about latest API CVE in popular products

Test Library

Discover and find tests from Akto's 100+ API Security test library. Choose your template or add a new template to start your API Security testing.


Check out Akto's product documentation for all information related to features and how to use them.